Saturday, December 28, 2019

Socrates s Argument On Plato s Crito - 2097 Words

Plato’s Crito In this essay, I aim to prove that Socrates’s committed just act by examine surrendering his life. To do this, I will examine the arguments made by Plato to convince Socrates to escape from prison, as well as evaluating Socrates’s arguments against escaping from prison, while arguing that Socrates’s arguments were stronger. I will start by examining Plato’s arguments, and then move into Socrates’s arguments, while pointing out the strengths and weaknesses of both. I will touch on all of Socrates’s main arguments, however I will focus mainly on his argument that committing unjust actions can be harmful to one’s soul, and that having a ruined soul would render life not worth living. In his Crito, Plato lays out three arguments explaining why Socrates’s should escape the prison, flee to live in exile. He first argues that by choosing to remain in prison and be executed, Socrates would be hurting Plato in two ways; by forcing Plato to lose a good friend, and by hurting Plato’s reputation. Plato believes that since people will not be aware that Socrates chose to remain in prison, they will assume that Plato had the chance to help Socrates escape, and that he wasn’t willing to spend the money or put in the effort. This will lead people to believe that Plato cares more about his finances than his friend, and his reputation will be damaged beyond repair. This argument relies on Plato’s belief that is wrong to commit an act that will hurt a friend. I find thisShow MoreRelatedTry to Persuade Socrates Friends to Save Him Against His Will1191 Words   |  5 PagesTry to persuade the Socrates`s friends to save him, against his will. Socrates Is one of the most colorful figures of the ancient Greek world, who the strangeness of privacy life have always been of special philosophical and political science. He was convict to death because he does not believe in God and corrupted the youth people to do the same. In Plato`s dialogue Crito, Socrates spent his last time in the prison. Crito is coming to save Socrates and have plans how toRead MoreThe Rational Vs. The Emotional1573 Words   |  7 Pagesdefinitely the case with Crito and Socrates in â€Å"Crito† by Plato. Socrates and Crito are having an intimate conversation about reasons why Socrates should escape. Socrates is charged on corrupting the minds of the youth in Athens. Crito, who is Socrates student and close friend, tries to persuade him to escape because he did not believe Socrates committed any actual crime. Socrates, on the other hand, gives his own reasons for staying in jail. Crito’s argument for Socrates to escape from jail are moreRead MoreComparison Between Crito and Apology1661 Words   |  7 PagesComparison between Crito and Apology For these two articles that we read in Crito and Apology by Plato, we could know Socrates is an enduring person with imagination, because he presents us with a mass of contradictions: Most eloquent men, yet he never wrote a word; ugliest yet most profoundly attractive; ignorant yet wise; wrongfully convicted, yet unwilling to avoid his unjust execution. Behind these conundrums is a contradiction less often explored: Socrates is at once the most Athenian, mostRead MorePlato s Life And Accomplishments874 Words   |  4 PagesPlato, a Greek philosopher, was born in Athens, in 428 B.C. under the name Aristoles. In his youth, he was a wrestler, that’s how he got the name ‘Plato’, that was his ring name. Plato means broad or flat, his shoulder were broad and his forehead was flat. He won a few trophies for wrestling but never made it to the Olympics at Olympia. He later change more toward the arts, and he wrote plays, and poetry, but in never won in any of his writin g competitions. â€Å"Having failed to win an Olympic goldRead MoreThe Philosopher And The Filmmaker Michael Moore983 Words   |  4 Pagesagitators that had similar motivations and ways of achieving them. An example would be the philosopher Socrates and the filmmaker Michael Moore. Despite some small differences in approach, these two have many significant similarities as agitators. The most obvious similarity between Socrates and Moore is that they are agitators, but it is more than them just advocating social and political change. It s the methods in which they did so that were so similar. Both of them seemed to address issues or putRead MoreSocrates World Views1549 Words   |  7 PagesSocrates Paper The goal of this paper is to discern and construct the world views of Socrates through the various readings, lectures and videos that we have seen in class. Some of these sources include: Socrates by G. Rudebusch; excerpts from The Last Days of Socrates by Plato; and The Allegory of a Cave. Of the nine world views covered in class, I will delve into my interpretation of four of them as seen through the various sources that we have been exposed to in class. These four world views willRead MoreWhat is the purpose of the ‚Äà ²speech of the laws‚Äà ´, in Plato‚Äà ´s Crito? How is it related to Crito‚Äà ´s political opinions and preferences as expressed in this dialogue?2082 Words   |  9 Pagesï » ¿PH207 Patrick McKeon 11339276 Amos Edelheit What is the purpose of the ‘speech of the laws’, in Plato’s Crito? How is it related to Crito’s political opinions and preferences as expressed in this dialogue? Introduction In the following essay I will be discussing the purpose of the speech of laws in Plato’s Crito. I will also be discussing its relation to Crito’s political opinions and preferences as expressed in the dialogue. I will be focussing on the purpose of the speech of laws. In myRead MoreSocrates Crito2666 Words   |  11 Pagesthe dialogue takes place at Socrates’ prison cell, where he awaits his execution just days away. It started with Socrates waking up and finding his friend and loyal disciple Crito there. When Socrates asked how Crito got inside the prison at that early an hour, Crito told him that he simply knows the guard and has done the guard some favor. Crito then informed Socrates that the ship from Delos has already come in and tomorrow will be his execution. Socrates then told Crito about a dream he had, a womanRead MoreEssay on Socrates Fight for Justice1101 Words   |  5 PagesApology and Crito there is an attempt by Socrates to defend himself in cou rt and defend his choice to receive the death penalty when found guilty. Although he makes very valid and strong arguments throughout one can only wonder why such a wise person would choose death over life. The following essay will analyze three quotes from Apology and Crito, find the correlation between them, and reveal any flaws that may exsist inside these arguments made by Socrates. In Plato’s Apology Socrates explains toRead MorePlato And Aristotles Philosophy Opinions On Piety And Religion1472 Words   |  6 Pagesmention: Socrates, Plato and Aristotle, who they create the earliest western philosophy, their philosophic ideas influence our modern society and culture in many aspects. As we read The Trial and Death of Socrates: Four Dialogues, we can get close to the thinking of these two philosophic giants at the same time: the author Plato, and the main characters Socrates, who was Plato’s teacher. The book includes four dialogues between Socrates and his friends or disciples: Euthyphro, Apology,Crito and Phaedo

Friday, December 20, 2019

Government Intervention in the Economy Are Monetary and...

Subject Area: Economics Topic: Deficit Spending Essential Question: Should the government use instruments of monetary and fiscal stimulus policies to reactivate the economy? Imagine people living in parks called Bushville’s, lines for soup kitchens that go for blocks, and all across the country kids running away from home travelling on trains searching for your next meal. This is just a taste of what 2009 could have been, but thankfully, the year did not go down this way although it will be remembered for global economic crises and change. For the first time in three decades, the United States was forced to leave its monetarist for m of economy and start to use Keynesian fiscal measures in order to try to revive its economy. Since then,†¦show more content†¦In fact, that is a standard response in financial crises† (Krugman). In response to the 2008 global financial market meltdown, governments around the world demonstrate they agree with this since they are using fiscal measures to alleviate the recession. Monetary Stimulus consists of the â€Å"regulation of the money to influence economy wide activity such as inflation, employment, and economic growth† (McEachern 385). This form of stimulus is the most accepted one by the world, due to the monetarist school of thought developed by Milton Freidman a University of Chicago economist and Nobel Prize winner whose ideas have become very popular among nations in the last three decades due to the very conservative form of running an economy it believes. In addition, monetary stimuli have proved to be the quickest way come out of a recession. According to University of Pennsylvania economist Bernardo Vega a top economist in the Dominican Republic and well known around the world, manipulation of the United States Federal Reserve’s key interest rate is a great way to promote investment. He says, Lowering the Fed’s key interest rate will have a positive effect on lenders and promotes investment that is correct; it should not have a negative effect on saving because if all the major countries in the world are doing it at the same time the savings have nowhere else to go (Vega). Monetary stimulus and deficit spending, in the formShow MoreRelatedDiscuss The Best Option For Australia And Will Justify The Rationale1706 Words   |  7 PagesIntroduction The use of both monetary and fiscal policies has been specifically aimed at reducing inflation and implementing policies for sustained economic growth. This paper will present a discussion on the definitions of each policy while examining their role in economy. Based on the obtained insights, the paper will discuss the best option for Australia and will justify the rationale. In the end, the discussion will be given a conclusive shape in which the key learning will be summarized andRead MoreThe Great Recession2780 Words   |  12 PagesIntroduction The U.S. economy is currently experiencing its worst crisis since the Great Depression. The crisis started in the home mortgage market, especially the market for so-called â€Å"subprime† mortgages, and is now spreading beyond subprime to prime mortgages, commercial real estate, corporate junk bonds, and other forms of debt. Total losses of U.S. banks could reach as high as one-third of the total bank capital. The crisis has led to a sharp reduction in bank lending, which in turnRead MoreEurope Economic Crisis55278 Words   |  222 PagesISSN 0379-0991 Economic Crisis in Europe: Causes, Consequences and Responses EUROPEAN ECONOMY 7|2009 EUROPEAN COMMISSION The European Economy series contains important reports and communications from the Commission to the Council and the Parliament on the economic situation and developments, such as the Economic forecasts, the annual EU economy review and the Public ï ¬ nances in EMU report. Subscription terms are shown on the back cover and details on how to obtain the list of sales agentsRead More1. Monetary and Fiscal Policy and Its Impact on Business Decision Making 2. Open Economy Macroeconomics-Mundell –Fleming Model and Its Application5514 Words   |  23 Pages1. Monetary and fiscal policy and its impact on business decision making 2. Open economy macroeconomics-Mundell –Fleming Model and its application FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICY IN INDIA AND ITS IMPACT ON Business Decision Making. What is monetary policy? Monetary policy is the management of money supply and interest by central banks to influence prices and employment. Monetary policy works through expansion or contraction of investment consumption expenditure. MonetaryRead MoreMacroeconomics Project6761 Words   |  28 Pagesbusiness cycle analysis is the existence of large fluctuations in aggregate economic activity that arise from what seem to be small shocks. This anomaly is what motivated the research into the financial accelerator. The financial accelerator is a possible explanation for these disproportional fluctuations. Changes in the credit market amplify and spread the initial shocks. This is explanation fits particularly well when firms and households are overextended or highly leveraged. This credit-marketRead MoreEdexcel Igcse Economics Answer49663 Words   |  199 PagesTamer has lowered prices to encourage his customers to buy CDs. However, he has been unsuccessful and the shop is being closed down. Answers: Section A: The Market System Getting started: (b) Market systems encourage resources such as raw materials, land, machines and workers to flow into the thriving markets and out of the declining markets. In thriving markets prices will be rising. This means that sellers will probably be making healthy profits. These healthy profits will attract more Read MoreHow Global Economic Environment Is Affecting International Marketers?11351 Words   |  46 Pageswe are going through the most severe global financial crisis since the days of Great Depression. Originated in USA, economic recession is affecting all the major players of world economy. Governments and major policy makers of world economy have taken notice of the urgency of the situation and frantic steps are undertaken to stem the rot. At the core of the term ‘recession’, spirals of several financial mistakes are intermingled. Many global opportunities have arisen because of the clustering ofRead MoreUK - Analysis Report31935 Words   |  128 Pages As the governance indicators illustrate, the UK is one of the most successful nations in terms of the application of rule of law, control of corruption, government effectiveness and regulatory quality. Furthermore, acc ording to the World Bank s governance indicators for 2008, the country was given a high percentile rank of 94.3 on government effectiveness. The heavy involvement of the UK in the war on terror in Afghanistan and Iraq seems to have had some negative consequences. The threat of terrorismRead MoreInside the Meltdown49737 Words   |  199 PagesSHEILA BAIR ... FDIC [Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.], established 75 years ago in the Great Depression. ... How does it feel being head of FDIC during another grand crisis? It s a very important place to be right now. We re getting a lot of media attention, and I think that s positive because I think the FDIC is all about public confidence. That s how we maintain the stability with people having confidence in our brand and our insurance guarantee, and I think we ve done that fairly successfullyRead MoreInternational Management67196 Words   |  269 PagesEducation iii This page intentionally left blank Preface C hanges in the global business environment continue unabated. The global financial crisis and economic recession have challenged some assumptions about globalization and economic integration, but they have also underscored the interconnected nature of global economies. Most countries and regions around the world are inextricably linked, yet profound differences in institutional and cultural environments persist. The challenges for international

Thursday, December 12, 2019

Community Management And Organizations - Ways To Express Views

Questions: LINK6501. Identify the various ways that employees expressed their job dissatisfaction on the LINK6502. Shaun ONeills commitment to the LINK organization dwindled over his two years of employment. Discuss the factors that affected his organizational commitment.PFIZER1. Did Hank McKinnell handle the Medicare situation and WARN memo in an ethical manner? What would you have done if you were in Mr. McKinnells place?2. What is your opinion about how Pfizer is acting as an organizational citizen? What have they done that has shown good/inadequate social responsibility?3. What factors should have been considered in Pfizers decision to restructure their newly merged organization? Do you think they made good decisions? What would you have done differently with regard to laying off employees? Answers: LINK 650 (1). Job dissatisfaction in an organization can be expressed by four different ways. These are exit, voice, loyalty and neglect. Exit makes the employee leave the organization, voice is the constructive and active to improve the conditions, loyalty makes the employee to passively and optimistically wait for the improved conditions and neglect causes the passive worsening of the conditions. The employees of LINK 650 to express their job dissatisfaction collectively displayed all these characteristics. During the initial period of the job tenure, the employees followed the theories of organizational behavior to build up the bondage among the group members that helped them to get over the grueling work and bad weather (Week 1 Chapter 1 Slides). The characteristic of exit appeared first for the expression of job dissatisfaction when the tough supervisors of LINK 650 abused the employees and the employees decided to quit their jobs. Then arrived the characteristic of neglect where the employees faked their ailments of a backache and left the rig with paid sick leaves. Then it was the turn of voice where the employees signed the union cards for unionizing the organization. Finally, loyalty made Shaun continue his job even after the horrible work experience he had on the seas, with utter dissatisfaction for the job. (2). Organizational commitment is the process by which a member of an organization is psychologically attached to the organization. According to the theories of organizational behavior, it essentially describes the feeling of the employees towards their jobs and their commitment towards their organization (Week 1 Video 1 Making Systems Thinking Sexy). According to the models of organizational commitments, three distinct components can be attributed to the commitment of an employee towards an organization. The affective model explains the emotional attachment of an employee with the organization. During the initial joining period of Shaun in LINK 650, he was proud and enthusiastic about his selection and exhibited high levels of affection. Therefore, it was affective commitment that made him stay. Continuance model explains the commitment of the employee based on continuity that makes him believe that quitting a respectable organization will be a costly decision with unacceptable unemplo yment duration. Shaun did not leave the well-reputed organization LINK 650 and continued to work based on his knowledge of organizational behavior as this might cost him a hard-earned job with the risk of unemployment. The normative model makes the employee stay back with the organization by feeling obligated and believing that it is correct way to do. Shaun was taught in his class of organizational behavior that he must continue to give his best irrespective of the tough situation, which kept him committed to his organization for two years of employment. Pfizer (1). WARN (Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act) provides protection to the employees along with their families and the entire community by making the employers provide an advanced notice of 60 days prior to closing the plants and covering the mass layoffs (Collins). The Medicaid laws are designed to reduce the costs of the prescription drugs to provide the beneficiaries with cheaper medications, especially in the economically weaker zone. Mr. McKinnell stated that he was willing to resolve the budget problem of Michigan. However, he stated as well that removal of the Medicaid policies would leverage the local jobs. This was not at all ethical and it was completely a corporate decision. Had I been in place of Mr. McKinnell, I would have arranged for increasing the business development and manufacturing of Pfizer in economically weaker zone of Kalamazoo, which would have boosted up the economical status of the dwellers, without terminating their jobs (Week 1 Video 2 Creating High Performance Workplaces). (2). The officials from Pfizer stated that their decision to base the two global centers of manufacturing and drug safety in the area of Kalamazoo indicated good organizational citizenship and strong local commitment. According to me, Pfizer did not act as an organizational citizen as it intended to break up the world class operational facilities at Kalamazoo rather than keeping it together and ignored the skills of the people (Week 2 Chapter 2 Slides). The estimation of the employees to be terminated from their jobs was supposed to be approximately 2000 in the area of Kalamazoo. Moreover, they decided to halt or move the research and development facility that was once the most effective in the industry. These factors collectively pulled down the economic stability of Kalamazoo as Michigan was already facing budgetary issues and Pfizer only added to its problems, rather than solving it. The existing manufacturing site was also in a vulnerable state and therefore, I can conclude that Pfi zer did not show adequate social responsibility by increasing the financial burden of Kalamazoo. (3). The merging of a smaller organization with a larger organization needs to focus on the welfare of the employees, as they are the ones who are the driving force of an organization. Pharmacia was a much smaller organization when compared to Pfizer and therefore the existing employees of Pharmacia had bigger expectations of development. However, in contrast to this theory, Pfizer initiated the deal with an announcement for cost savings of $2.5 billion that might hit the employees and the operations. This was not a very good decision and they should have cared for the poor people of Kalamazoo, who were much dependent on the earnings from Pharmacia. I would have certainly not promoted this idea of closure of operations and termination of jobs, as it hits the working force of an organization at the most. I would have planned for newer investments as this could be beneficial for the business, as well as the people involved (Week 5 Video 2 Expectancy Theory).

Wednesday, December 4, 2019

Does God Care if Youre Gay free essay sample

Do you think God cares if your hair is straight or curly? Do you think God cares if your teeth are shiny white or orange juice stain yellow? Do you think God cares if you like the same sex? If you answered â€Å"Yes† to any of these questions, you judge yourself right along with judging others. God does not care if your hair is straight or curly: you were created in His image. God does not care if your teeth are shiny white or orange juice yellow: you were created in His image. God does not care if you like the same sex: you were created in His image. Unlike some, others do believe that God cares about being a homosexual or a heterosexual. Those that do believe that God cares what kind of love one is in taste with are those that follow the path of religion (and yes, even those who do not follow a religion do believe it is wrong), such as Muslims, Buddhist, Jains, Sikhs, Jews, and Hindus. We will write a custom essay sample on Does God Care if Youre Gay? or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page Muhsin Hendricks is one of the only openly gay imams (the person who leads prayers in a mosque). At one point this man had married and had three children with his wife for fear that his family would not approve of him being homosexual. Throughout their marriage, his Muslim wife knew that Muhsin was not heterosexual, yet they tried the best they both could to pretend like he was, until they finally got a divorce and went their separate ways. After the divorce, Muhsin came out in full force, the only willing participant out of Muhsin’s family that would listen to him, was his mother. His mother loved his son for who he was, and for that, Muhsin was the only person at her bedside as she slowly slipped into God’s hands. The Qur’an, states â€Å"For ye practice your lusts on men in preference to women: ye are indeed a people transgressing beyond boundsAnd we rained down on them a shower (of brimstone),† (7:80-84); this means that homosexuals should be stoned t o death since there is no reasons for their ways. To Muslims being homosexual is a sin and it is unforgivable. Having said that being homosexual is a sin, the Buddhist believe that being a homosexual is karma coming back from a past life for participating in a form of heterosexual misconduct. If a man wishes to become a Monk, he mustn’t have any sexual relations, including those of the same sex, the same goes for women if they wish to become nuns. When the Dalai Lama is asked about Buddhism and homosexuality, he merely replies that it is wrong yet has no valid reason as to why that is. Many believe the reason that Buddhist do not agree with homosexuality is because the Buddha has been recorded opposing any person who openly expresses cross-gender features or strong homosexual desires and actions. Karma has a way of going around and around, at least the Jains believe so. Jains believe that if one is a homosexual, they will forever live with bad karma. The reason behind their belief that the homosexual will forever live life with bad karma is because their feelings for others of the same sex or sexual acts with those of the same sex would have to be outside of marriage. Marriage, in almost all religions including Jainism, is for only one man and one woman; never two men and two women. How contradicting it is because the Jains believe in separation of church and state. Government would be better off without the input of all religions of whether or not a man and man or a woman and a woman can or cannot get married. Yet they still believe that the homosexual will live with bad karma? Being a homosexual is not a big deal to Sikhs, as long as they don’t wish to get married. Marriage is only for a man and a woman, how else would the next generation come to be? Sikhs have a controversial view on whether or not being a homosexual is wrong; in the view of marriage, being a homosexual is merely impossible but in the view of homosexuals being damned to Hell, the person does not have a higher rate than that of a heterosexual. When Sikhs are asked about their views on homosexuality, they refer to marriage. If there are two women that love each other as much as a man and a woman love one another, can they not get married right beside them? Although two women cannot bear a child alone, they can raise a child together. However, homosexuality is not part of the Sikhism lifestyle and is therefore deemed, wrong. One can express feelings for a person of the same sex, but as soon as either party act on the feelings, it is frowned upon, according to Jews. The basis of the prohibition against homosexual acts comes from two biblical verses in Leviticus: â€Å"Do not lie with a male as one lies with a woman; it is an abhorrence† (Leviticus 18:22) and â€Å"If a man lies with a male as one lies with a woman, the two of them have done an abhorrent thing; they shall be put to death—their blood guilt is upon them† (Leviticus 20:13). The Torah considers a homosexual act between two men to be an abhorrent thing that is punishable by death. The prohibition against lesbianism is not as strict as the prohibition against male homosexuality because the Torah does not come out and prohibit les ¬bianism, and because lesbianism does not involve the spilling of seed. Although the Jewish faith teaches nothing about homosexuality, it is still frowned upon in their eyes. Yet another faith in which being a homosexual is a controversial issue is with the Hindu faith. A form of love that is shared between a man and a woman in no way could be shared between a man and man or a woman and a woman, some Hindus believe. However, if a homosexual can feel love for a person of the same sex, isn’t that love the same love that can be shared between a heterosexual couple? In Hinduism, one of the big parts about being married is being able to bear a child; something in which a homosexual couple would not be able to do with just one another. However, there are other ways that a homosexual could have a child, adoption, for example. Nowhere in the sacred texts does it say that a romantic love can only be between a man and woman, thus a man and a man or a woman and a woman are at their own free will of being romantically involved with one another. Notice how God hasn’t had much say in which He cares if a person likes the same sex? Yes, the sacred texts of every religion are God’s words, but doesn’t He love all his children? Does He not want all of His children to love one another and accept each other as we are? If a homosexual wants to be a homosexual, they have that right and they should not be afraid to tell others how they feel inside. Instead, all should have welcome arms and give that person the love and support we all want. What if being a heterosexual wasn’t the norm? Would religion be the same? Every person has a right to believe in what they wish, however, the world would be a much more peaceful place if being a homosexual was not frowned upon by Muslims, Buddhist, Jains and Sikhs, and instead of homosexuality being a controversial issue among Jews and Hindus, why don’t all religions come together and recognize their brothers and sisters are not all the same?

Sunday, November 24, 2019

Healthy Truckers Go the Extra Mile!

Healthy Truckers Go the Extra Mile! If you’re a trucker who’s serious about your career, make sure you think about ways to maintain a healthy lifestyle- both in and out of the driver’s seat. Do you own a trucking company or are part of a company’s management team? Consider implementing a driver wellness plan. Healthy drivers will help minimize staff retention challenges and make open positions on your team more attractive to newer, younger drivers. Driver wellness programs are growing in popularity across the country and for good reason- they help prevent illness, boost productivity, and enhance life satisfaction. Healthy drivers are happier, better employees who stay at their jobs longer. They also help reverse the trend of increasing trucker turnover, a problem that has burdened the industry for the past few years as older truckers are retiring and aren’t being replaced by new drivers.What are the reasons behind this trend? For many, these jobs, with tough, unhealthy working conditi ons and limited opportunities, aren’t as appealing as they once were. But thoughtful, well-designed wellness programs can help offset some of these unappealing aspects of truck driving.In order for driver wellness programs to have a deep and lasting impact, they need to be proactive in their efforts to work with drivers, and should be thoroughly holistic, addressing all major dimensions of wellness:Physical: proper nutrition, exercise, and lifestyle choicesEmotional: promoting emotional healthIntellectual: strategies for sound mental health and developmentOccupational: creating true job satisfactionSocial: forging meaningful community connectionsSpiritual: creating and following a meaningful set of guiding valuesHere’s the bottom line: Trucking companies should make sincere and measurable efforts to support the wellness of their drivers, and when drivers make health and wellness an important part of their lives, everyone benefits.Why Wellness in Trucking Needs to Go th e Extra MileRead More at Supply Chain Management Review

Thursday, November 21, 2019

Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1

Critique - Essay Example Homosexual marriages cannot be justified without drawing help from logical fallacies and making broad generalizations. Summary of the Article In his article, Sullivan argues that gay marriage is eligible for legalization by all means. Marriage is a social contract. Marriage is a physical and emotional bond between two people irrespective of their gender. People, who have been denied to fall in love with somebody despite the natural love they feel can best understand how it feels when a gay is denied the right to get married. Illegalizing gay marriage is a torture for the homosexual people whereas legalization of gay marriage would provide the homosexual people with grounds to have normal relationships with their parents and loved ones rather than being socially outcast. Gay parenting does not have any unfavorable impacts on the children’s psychology, Homosexual marriages have existed throughout the history in forms different from the traditional marriage. Dating, love, and rel ationship; everything becomes meaningless for them when they cannot get married. Without marriage, there is no commitment. Homosexuality occurs naturally, and this challenges all conservative reasons against the legalization of gay marriage. Therefore, gay marriage should be legalized. ... ls by excessively making use of such emotional words as â€Å"most public affront possible† (Sullivan 404) and calling the traditional form of marriage between a man and a woman a â€Å"circular fiet† (Sullivan 404). While referring to marriage as a public contract, Sullivan has just highlighted one aspect of marriage i.e. â€Å"bond between two people† thus excluding all others who are affected by the marriage between the two people that include but are not limited to their parents, and their own children. Marriage is not just about two people, it has its implications on other members of the family, as well as upon the nation as a whole that might be already suffering from a negative population growth rate, and homosexual marriages are definitely going to aggravate this social problem. Sullivan has made a logical fallacy by limiting the intrinsic status of the heterosexual marriage to its understanding as intrinsically procreative. Sullivan has a preconceived no tion that a marriage between an adult and a minor is unsustainable as one of the two parties does not understand the contract. If an adult and a minor marry each other with mutual consent, Sullivan should acknowledge that as an emotional bond too just like he approves of the emotional bond between two homosexuals. Sullivan has made broad generalizations that are unfair. For example, he says that everybody who speaks in favor of heterosexual marriage does not do so because he/she disparages the homosexual marriage, but because not doing so means demanding human virtue in excess. I don’t believe that this is the reason why people support heterosexual marriages. People support heterosexual marriages primarily because of their religious beliefs, and then because of considering its positive impacts on the society.